|
Critique
1 Rubric
|
||||
|
Criteria
|
Less
than Adequate
|
Adequate
|
Good
|
Excellent
|
| Describes significant similarities and differences between sets of standards | Few similarities and differences described are accurate and signficant OR only limited number identified (0-5) | Most similarities and differences described are accurate and signficant (6-7) | Almost all similarities and differences described are accurate and signficant (8) | Accurately described multiple, significant similarities and differences (9-10) |
| Provides effective arguments in support of position | Ineffective or insufficient arguments presented (0-2) | Limited but effective arguments presented OR only some arguments are effective (3) | Sufficient
and mostly effective arguments presented (4) |
Effective arguments presented (5) |
| Uses textual evidence to support arguments | Insufficient and irrelevant evidence provided (0-2) | Limited but relevant evidence OR sufficient but only somewhat relevant evidence provided (3) | Mostly sufficient and relevant evidence provided (4) | Sufficient and relevant evidence provided to support arguments (5) |
|
Well written:
|
Rarely (0-2) | Sporadically (3) | In most instances (4) | Consistently throughout (5) |